A reporter recently asked what positive effects moderating housing prices could have. Here are my thoughts:
From what I observe the moderation in housing prices could have the following positive effects:
- Lower increases in property taxes from higher assessments which have hit many communities and neighborhoods very hard over the past several years.
- First time buyers taking more care in purchasing a home
- Not paying more than they can afford
- Making sure to do all of their due diligence inspections etc.
- Not having buyers remorse because they rushed their home purchases an bought before seeing enough houses
- Fewer creative financing deals such as option ARMs means that fewer buyers will get in over their heads.
Â
The reporter also raised some potential benefits:
Should housing be viewed less as an investment and more as a living expense? Will a moderation in home price appreciation help bring about this view?
- I think your home should be viewed primarily as a place to live unless your plan to sell it in the near future. Even if you saw it as an investment, it would be a speculative investment. I think if people actually calculated their true return on housing it would be much lower than they think. Maintenance, taxes, and buy/sell costs are often left out of the calculation.
Could a flattening of home prices spur consumers to diversify their portfolios which may be heavy with housing?
- As much as I would like to see this I don’t think it will happen for two reasons:
- Housing is seen as a great investment by many
- Consumers may just spend vs. invest the money they would save. Buying a house is the major form of savings for many people.
Will home buyers, particularly first-timers — find more affordable opportunities?
- Yes, but since housing markets are very fragmented, an overall slowing in appreciation may not affect some hot neighborhoods. It is my understanding that in most metro areas that saw a lot of appreciation this decade, houses at the low end of the market are still selling strongly, it’s the move-up housing that is suffering the most.